Christopher Columbus and his monument Columbia : being a concordance of choice…
Read "Christopher Columbus and his monument Columbia : being a concordance of choice…" Online
This book is available in the public domain. Start reading the digital edition below.
START READING FULL BOOKBook Preview
A short preview of the book’s content is shown below to give you an idea of its style and themes.
This isn't a story with a clear beginning, middle, and end. Instead, it's a snapshot of a heated national conversation. Published around 1892, the book gathers writings from politicians, poets, and everyday citizens all debating one thing: Should America build a colossal 'Monument to Columbus' to celebrate the 400th anniversary of his voyage?
The Story
The 'plot' is the debate itself. On one side, you have soaring speeches calling Columbus a visionary hero who connected two worlds. On the other, there are sharp critiques questioning his legacy and whether he's the right symbol for a modern America. The book lays out these arguments side-by-side through formal odes, newspaper clippings, and fundraising appeals. You watch the idea of the monument swell with patriotic pride, then get poked full of holes by doubters. The mystery isn't about Columbus in the 1490s, but about what he meant to Americans in the 1890s.
Why You Should Read It
I found this absolutely gripping because it feels so raw and unfinished. You're not reading a polished historian's conclusion. You're in the messy middle of people figuring out their history. It shows that arguing about statues and national symbols isn't a new thing at all. The passion in these pages—both for and against the monument—is palpable. It made me think about how every generation has to decide which parts of its past to celebrate and which to question.
Final Verdict
Perfect for history buffs who are tired of dry textbooks and want to feel the heat of a real debate. It's also great for anyone curious about how public memory gets shaped. If you prefer straightforward narratives, this collage-style book might frustrate you. But if you like primary sources and forming your own conclusions from a chorus of conflicting voices, this 'concordance' is a unique and thought-provoking find.
You are viewing a work that belongs to the global public domain. You are welcome to share this with anyone.